Advantages of the Biochemical Approach over Traditional Systems (Stewart/SID, Base Excess, Physiological)

Mathematical coherency with

The true nature of carbon dioxide as a neutral compound, not as a volatile acid

The isoelectric principle (all cations are acids, all anions are bases)

The biochemical origin and interactions of acids and anions

Systematic approach to high anion gap disorders, where anions (measured or unmeasured) are a product of disturbances in cellular respiratory pathways.

The elevated anion points toward the altered step

Anaerobic glycolysis yields lactate

Krebs cycle

Fatty acids instead of glucose yields ketone bodies (diabetes, starvation, and alcohol ketoacidosis)

Aminoacids instead of glucose yield organic anions (organic acidemias i.e methylmalonic, isovaleric and propionic acidemias). These are usually “unmeasured”. However, high AG in absence of lactate and ketone bodies points directly to OA.

CO2 buildup in plasma points toward a functioning Krebs cycle in absence of proper water production in mitochondrial respiratory chain.

Pathway of CO production from odd-chain fatty acids in Krebs cycle.

Mitochondrial respiratory chain

Lactate in presence of hypercapnia

Low bicarbonate levels with high AG / low BE

Prioritizes and facilitates diagnosis and treatment of high anion-gap disturbances, as they are the most life-threatening of all acid-base disturbances. This is of vital importance for health personnel in emergency, operating room, and critical care/intensive care units.

High Anion Gap / Low Base Excess disturbances are commonly just managed with IV fluid therapy. However, a clear understanding of the underlying biochemical disturbance leads to a faster diagnosis and precise management.

Proposes a differentiation between two important and often confused terms: respiration and ventilation.

Respiration refers exclusively to cellular ATP production.

Ventilation refers to pulmonary gas exchange processes.

Facilitates insight on biochemical pathophysiology, clinical manifestations, and therapeutical approach of diseases such as Urea Cycle Disorders and Organic Acidemias; which are often lethal and common in areas like Neonatal Intensive Care Units.

UCD and salicylate poisoning usually present alkaline pH with high anion gap. This tends to baffle clinicians, because there is no apparent relationship of alkaline pH with the severe clinical presentation. However, when pH of urea and salicylate are considered, the explanation is clear:

Urea pH is 9.8, salicylate pH is 13.

Both can block cellular respiration by either blocking Krebs cycle (Urea) or mitochondrial respiratory chain (salicylates), which leads to cellular respiration disturbances and anion production.

Buildup of both substances in plasma alkalinizes plasma pH, while anions build up.

Provides insight into more effective ways to treat and solve electrolyte imbalance such as hyperkalemia, based on principles of transmembrane electrochemical gradients. This is important for nephrologists, cardiologists, and intensive care unit doctors.

Hyperkalemia responds to sodium intake. Given that K+ is more abundant intracellularly, when Na+ levels are being depleted (inadequate intake, excess loss due to diuretics etc), K+ moves towards the interstitial and plasma compartments to compensate electrical charges and maintain cellular function. All clinical manifestations of hyperkalemia are related to altered electrical properties such as depolarization. Restoring Na+ levels and preventing further loss will stabilize membrane functions.

Opens a pathway to further explore other ion / electrolyte imbalances such as hyperphosphatemia seen commonly in persons with CKD.

Further exploration into the production and management of H+ ions reveal that intracellular acidosis (H+ buildup) causes cell membrane depolarization. This opens a new path to understand cellular depolarization physiology and pathology on a deeper level, providing grounds for neurologists, cardiologists, physical therapists and gastroenterologists.

The current paradigm in depolarization is the influx of Na+ ions, followed by efflux of K+ ions and later influx of Ca++ ions.

H+ ions produced by cellular respiration (normally found in water molecules, but present in weak acids in high AG acidosis) exit the cell via NHE (sodium-hydrogen exchange channels).

9 main families of NHE channels, out of which 5 are involved in syndromes that include seizures or epilepsy.

H+ ions are so small that the electrical currents they produce weren’t documented in the original experiments. Now, it has been mathematically described that H+ ions produce a current of 11 fA (fentoAmperes, 1*10-14)

Therefore, the Na+ influx is not random but a mechanism to keep electrical balance of the exiting H+ ions produced in mitochondria. This correlates to the higher electrical activity of cells with more mitochondria, such as nervous system and muscles.

Explains a different approach to Anion Gap and Base Excess, which are mirror values of cellular respiratory disturbances.

Anion gap is usually overlooked or even ignored by clinicians.

Base excess (i.e., negative base excess) is usually understood as dehydration or corrected with bicarbonate.

Bicarbonate is produced from the combination (not chemical reaction) of a dissociated water molecule and carbon dioxide.

Carbon dioxide is a byproduct of Krebs cycle.

Water is a byproduct of mitochondrial respiratory chain.

Carbonic anhydrase separates the Hydroxyl (OH-) ion from the Hydrogen (H+) ion, “mounting” them on carbon dioxide (an electrochemically neutral compound with two stable double bonds).

Therefore, in the presence of low base excess, low bicarbonate always means low water production, which points toward mitochondrial respiratory chain blockage or malfunction.

Traditional theory indicates bicarbonate replacement, which, though it masks acidemia, it does not solve the root cause of the problem.

Alternative explanation to physiological and clinical signs of acid-base disturbances

The author hypothesizes that disorders in cellular respiration would cause cells to require more oxygen to maintain minimum levels of ATP production (respiratory quotient). This can be the real cause of tachypnea and other altered breathing patterns such as Kussmaul and “metabolic alkalosis”-related tachypnea such as inborn errors of metabolism. Understanding the origin and mechanism of such clinical signs and symptoms will facilitate early diagnosis, treatment, and management.

Biochemical Classification of Acid-Base Disturbances

Respiratory acidosis

Common characteristics of respiratory acidosis include:

pH < 7.35

High Anion gap (st) >12

Base deficit < -2.0

All “CAT-MUDPILES” * acidosis cause disturbances in cellular respiration (2)

Clinical presentation includes shock, hypovolemia, cyanosis, hypotension, tachycardia, tachypnea, cold skin and prolonged capillary refill time. May include vomiting, nausea, drowsiness, or alterations in state of alertness.

The altered anions indicate the cellular respiratory disturbance. This allows prompt management decisions:

Step 1: Glycolysis

Elevated lactate is due to anaerobic glycolysis. It indicates hypoxia and/or hypovolemia. CO2 is low or normal due to low production (Krebs cycle). Treatment is oxygen and IV fluid or volume replacement.

Step 2: Citric Acid (Krebs) cycle

Elevated ketone bodies are due to fatty acid breakdown and/or use as substrates in the Krebs cycle. They indicate intracellular glucose deficit, fasting, or decompensated diabetes, probably precipitated by infection. The treatment is restoring intracellular glucose availability, insulin, IV fluids and antibiotics if indicated.

Organic anions (i.e., propionic, isovaleric, methylmalonic acid) result from using amino acids as a substrate for Krebs cycle. They indicate inborn (life-threatening) errors of metabolism, prolonged fasting or malignancies. The management is nutritional approach.

Step 3: Mitochondrial respiratory chain

Hypercapnic respiratory acidosis is due to mitochondrial respiratory chain blockage, probably caused by organophosphates, use of remdesivir (7) or antiretroviral agents, metformin (8), and other toxic agents (2). Since there is no water formation, there is no carbonic acid production and carbon dioxide accumulates in blood. Concomitant hyperlactatemia indicates that active glycolysis is taking place to produce ATP.

High CO₂ (hypercapnia)

Mild to severe hyperlactatemia (rescue mechanism for minimum ATP production)

In absence of contact with any chain uncoupler such as the aforementioned, mitochondrial inborn errors of metabolism should be considered and screened for.

“CAT MUDPILES”: Carbon dioxide/Cyanide poisoning, congenital heart failure, Aminoglucosides, Toluene/Teophyline, Methanol, Uremia, Diabetic/Alcoholic/Starvation ketoacidosis, Paracetamol/Phenphormin/Paraldehyde, Iron/Isoniazid/Inborn Errors of Metabolism, Lactic acidosis, Ethanol/Ethyleneglycol, Salycilate intoxication

Figure 1: Biochemical classification of acid-base disturbances

Source: Author’s classification with information provided in the text and references.

Respiratory alkalosis

Common characteristics of most cases of respiratory alkalosis are:

pH >7.45

High Anion gap, >12

Base deficit < -2

Low CO2 (<35 mm Hg arterial or < 40 mm Hg in venous blood sample) (hypocapnia - low production due to Krebs blockage)

Clinical characteristics include tachycardia, tachypnea, dizziness, shock, lethargy, altered state of mind, cerebral edema, liver failure, coma and/or death. Acidosis due to alterations in cellular energy production is masked by a potent alkali, which shifts plasma pH up.

The main respiratory alkalosis are:

Urea cycle disorders, including congenital or acquired variants, which can be lethal. Altered nitrogen metabolism allows an alkalinizing urea (pH 9.8) effect. Alpha ketoglutarate production blocks the Krebs cycle. The treatment is dialysis, and if the patient survives, a nutritional approach is granted.

Salicylate poisoning. Salicylate blocks the Krebs cycle and respiratory chain, causing organ failure and death. Respiratory acidosis or alkalosis will depend on the number of salicylates (pH 13) present in blood. The treatment includes hemodialysis, stopping the medication, gastric lavage, using activated charcoal, and IV fluids (9).

Metabolic acidosis

Common characteristics of metabolic acidosis include:

pH <7.35

Anion gap: normal. No other anions found.

Base excess - 2 to +2

CO2 normal.

Low bicarbonate with normal to high potassium.

Clinical presentation may include tachycardia, dehydration, vomiting and /or diarrhea. Renal causes may present with growth retardation and varying degrees of bone mineral disease.

If the biochemical presentation consists of low bicarbonate, high chloride, and normal to low potassium level, the most probable causes are:

Lower gastrointestinal losses (diarrhea, pancreatic or small bowel drainage). Management: replace IV fluids with bicarbonate.

Type 1 or type 2 Renal Tubular acidosis. Management: replace bicarbonate.

Other mechanisms (acid loads, dilution acidosis caused by excess of saline solution, cation excess resins, Hippurate). Management: remove the acid load.

If the biochemical presentation consists of low bicarbonate, high chloride, and high potassium levels (hyperkalemic metabolic acidosis with normal anion gap):

Type 4 renal tubular acidosis (primary or secondary mineralocorticoid deficiency, resistance, or renal tubular dysfunction) (10). The treatment is mineralocorticoid replacement if indicated. Hyperkalemia is corrected by normalizing sodium concentration in plasma.

Metabolic alkalosis

Common characteristics include:

pH >7.45

Anion gap normal to low (8-12 or lower)

Base excess: normal to high (-2 - +2 or higher)

CO2 normal.

Clinical presentations include:

Upper gastrointestinal tract - vomiting (hypertrophic pyloric stenosis), ingestion of sodium bicarbonate, milk-alkali syndrome. The disturbance is loss of fixed acid or gain of bicarbonate buffer. To treat, stop vomiting, or stop ingestion of causative agent.

Volume contraction due to renal causes and acid losses, especially hyperaldosteronism or loop or thiazide diuretics (volume contraction). Management includes stopping diuretics. Study aldosterone function, discard/manage secondary causes of hyperaldosteronism (e.g., hypertension medications, heart failure) (10).